5 builders who never spoke to each other
Enter a category buyers already recognise
Naming a new category means paying to teach the market what you are before you can sell anything, and the inventor is rarely the one who collects. Taking a practice people already follow and doing it visibly better keeps the explaining short and the demand pre-existing.
The method
- 01
Bootstrappers should resist the urge to invent a category, because you don't have the time, money or energy to teach the market what your thing even is.
- 02
Even the celebrated visionaries were riding momentum in an existing category; look for the pattern of a widespread product that everyone owns and nobody enjoys, and attack that gap.
- 03
Pick an established category that is still trending upward rather than a novel one; commoditised is acceptable, shrinking is not.
- 04
Assume you cannot manufacture demand; almost every successful product is an iteration sitting on demand that already accumulated in its category.
- 05
Look for demand that is already in motion and build for where those people are heading, rather than trying to start the movement yourself.
What it returned
- 2010
Jason Cohen on WP Engine (WordPress hosting, started 2010): bootstrapping the first 18 months would have gone badly with any other CMS; the size and growth of that market was critical.
- 1888
Kodak's 1888 camera itself built on earlier iterations, and every camera innovation since has ridden the category's growing demand.
- 2000
Xerox PARC produced the mouse, Ethernet, the laser printer and the windowed interface and profited from none of it; Bell Labs produced Unix, C and the laser with the same result; the companies that laid the fibre backbones went bankrupt in the 2000 crash.
Cell phones as the existing category, universal ownership as the momentum, general dislike as the opening for the iPhone.
Sources
- The $122Bn SEO Industry: 32 Success Stories (with Revenue Numbers) for 2024 - Detailed.comGlen Allsopp · detailed.com · The Gaps in the SEO Software Market · 2023-01-23
- Selling stuff on a busy beachJustin Jackson · justinjackson.ca · Why it's better to choose a growing market · undated
- Do entrepreneurs create demand?Justin Jackson · justinjackson.ca · New products evolve on top of existing demand · undated
- We sell saddles hereJustin Jackson · justinjackson.ca · We sell saddles here · undated
- Not disruptive, and proud of itJason Cohen · longform.asmartbear.com · The disruptors often don’t make the money. · 2010-04-12
- Chrome Extensions: ChatGPT, Pink Oceans, No-Code Tools - Trends.vcDru Riley · trends.vc · ☁️ Opportunities · 2023-08-30
- No New CategoriesGreg Kogan · gkogan.co · Enter Established or Emerging Categories · 2020-08-07
- Startups are a complex multivariable equationPreetam Nath · preetamnath.com · Startups are a complex multivariable equation · 2020-09-20
- How to copy your way to $1MTibo Louis-Lucas · tmaker.io · The framework · 2026-06-25
the second source
Three plays a week, for the phase you are in
No roundup of links, no news. Three tactics more than one builder arrived at separately, with the numbers each one returned and the disagreements left in.
More in positioning
- Do the boring market homework yourself7 unconnected · contested
- Build for a market you already belong to6 unconnected
- Aim everything at the segment you already win6 unconnected
- Narrow the category until you are its only occupant6 unconnected
- Pick the fight the incumbent cannot win6 unconnected
- Pick the market nobody is excited about6 unconnected