4 builders who never spoke to each other · contested
Look wrong for the category on purpose
Where competitors all present the same corporate surface, visual choice does the differentiating before a single feature is compared: bright colour, playful motion, a handmade look, a consistent house tint on every asset. Design is treated here as the competitive advantage itself rather than as decoration applied at the end.
Where this splits
Design is put forward as the durable competitive advantage, while one builder found that looking more modern than entrenched rivals lasted only until one of them redesigned.
6 claims against 1
Harry Dry · Karri Saarinen · Katelyn Bourgoin · Rob Hope
Make the visual difference your competitive advantage
- 01In a category where every competitor looks corporate, treat bright colour and playful animation as a deliberate differentiator so the brand reads as fun before a single feature gets compared.
- 02Where the category is already loved, sell the version that looks handmade rather than the machine-perfect one.
A design lead vanishes when rivals redesign
Looking more modern than entrenched competitors is a real advantage while it lasts, and it disappears the moment one of them redesigns.
- 03Drop a duotone in your own brand colour over each guest photo: it stops light caption text vanishing into light backgrounds and makes the show recognisable beside every other cover.
- 04Use design and brand as your actual competitive advantage rather than as surface decoration on the product.
- 05Strip the design to the minimum and let starkness be the signal: lowercase Helvetica on a plain yellow field.
What it returned
- 12
Ahrefs' animations and bright palette make it stand out against duller SEO tools, and it has held the top position in its category for close to 12 years.
The consumer psychologist Adam Ferrier ran tests on items people already adore, cookies among them, and found the flawed-looking batch was the one they wanted.
The red is the same one Rob Hope uses across Yo!, One Page Love and Email Love.
Prospects praised the Eventloot design as more contemporary than rival products. The trigger for shutting down was a long established competitor rebuilding with current design patterns.
Sources
- Ahrefs - Why We Buy 🧠Katelyn Bourgoin · customercamp.co · How Ahrefs Uses Buyer Psychology · undated
- Pratfall Effect - Why We Buy 🧠Katelyn Bourgoin · customercamp.co · 🧠 The Psychology of the Pratfall Effect · undated
- The genius of no name's brandHarry Dry · Marketing Examples · undated
- Why is the Angostura bitters label too big?Harry Dry · Marketing Examples · Why is the Angostura bitters label too big? · undated
- Yo! Podcast Artwork Illustrations - Rob HopeRob Hope · robhope.com · Part One: Standing out · 2020-10-21
- Eventloot: Failing to Listen Feedback Means $20,000 LossJustin Anyanwu · failory.com · What did finally provoke the shutdown of Eventloot? · undated · dissenting
- Inside Linear: Building with taste, craft, and focus | Karri Saarinen (co-founder, designer, CEO)Karri Saarinen · lennysnewsletter.com · 2023-10-08
the second source
Three plays a week, for the phase you are in
No roundup of links, no news. Three tactics more than one builder arrived at separately, with the numbers each one returned and the disagreements left in.
More in positioning
- Do the boring market homework yourself7 unconnected · contested
- Build for a market you already belong to6 unconnected
- Aim everything at the segment you already win6 unconnected
- Narrow the category until you are its only occupant6 unconnected
- Pick the fight the incumbent cannot win6 unconnected
- Pick the market nobody is excited about6 unconnected